As Americans continue to struggle with affordability, my organization wanted to study why residential electricity customers in some states are paying more for power than people in other states. This analysis paints a very clear picture about why this cost discrepancy is happening.
Specifically, states that moved away from traditional electric utility regulation and deregulated their electricity services are paying more for power. Our report found that in the contiguous United States, residential utility customers in deregulated states paid 60 percent more for electricity, on average in 2025, than residential customers in traditionally regulated states.
From 2024 to 2025, residential electricity prices in deregulated states climbed more than 7 percent, nearly double the 4 percent increase in regulated states — clearly showing that the cost gap between regulated and deregulated states is growing.
Because cost differences between regulated and deregulated states are so stark, we hope policymakers nationwide will look to this report’s findings as they seek ways to bring down power bills.
With that in mind, it’s worth understanding how we got to a place where millions of Americans in deregulated states are exposed to higher-than-necessary electric bills.
The electric industry was deregulated on a state-by-state basis, largely in the early 2000s. Today, about a quarter of U.S. states are deregulated.
In practical terms, deregulation meant that electric utilities were forced to divest their power plants and are prohibited from owning any form of electric generation. The theory behind electric industry deregulation was that a “competitive” generation market would drive prices down for consumers.
Considering that our study found that nine of the 10 most expensive states in the contiguous U.S. for residential electricity are deregulated, while every one of the 10 cheapest states relies on the traditional utility regulation, it is clear that “competitive” generation isn’t working.
The failures of electric deregulation are pretty obvious if you understand what deregulation eliminated: oversight of electric utilities by state government regulators (often called a public service commission) that set electricity prices for residential customers. Critically, this process of utility regulation is time-tested and orderly.
For example, in regulated states, utilities are required to propose long-term planning of generation, transmission and distribution of electricity. Next, state regulators review those utility proposals and authorize electric companies to build only the infrastructure needed, and they may bill customers only for costs regulators deem reasonable.
This regulatory process takes place publicly, with consumer advocates, industry groups, environmental advocates, citizens, and other groups each allowed to have their voices heard. Indeed, this model is the original public-private partnership that seeks to balance reasonable utility returns with affordable electricity for customers.
To be clear, regulated utilities can always improve how they operate and deliver electricity to customers. Our report makes one thing abundantly clear: When electric utilities are traditionally regulated, American families save money on their power bills.
The cost gap between electricity costs in regulated versus deregulated states is growing. This should be concerning for policymakers in deregulated states because, nationwide, we are seeing increased demand for electricity — from residential customers, commercial users and, now, data centers, the largest customers of all. Unless deregulated states change course, electricity rates in those states will rise faster than the rest of the country.
As policymakers look for ways to help make life in America more affordable, I urge them to consider our report. Our findings are irrefutable: deregulation is not an effective tool to lower power bills. Deregulated states should reconsider sensible utility regulation to help bring down electricity costs for residential customers.











Brad Viator | INSIDE SOURCES
Recent Articles
City of Prescott Announces Holger Durre as New Deputy City Manager
Prescott Regional Communications Center Earns Third Place Nationwide in T-Mobile Innovation in Community Competition
‘Art for Everyone’ Returns to Prescott
Prescott Valley Voters Shoot Down Local Propositions – Bill Williams